Roofing insurance rates comparison and coverage for homes and commercial buildings

Best Insurance Companies for Roofing Claims

When a storm damages your roof, filing an insurance claim shouldn’t be a nightmare. But the reality is, not all insurance companies handle roofing claims equally. Some are known for fast payouts and excellent service, while others are slow, difficult, and frustrating.

This article—featuring data from a recent consumer satisfaction survey—shows the best insurance companies for roofing claims, based on real homeowner experiences.


📊 Insurance Company Ratings Explained

The image above highlights a survey ranking 15 major U.S. insurance providers based on key claim-related metrics:

  • Accuracy of damage estimates

  • Problem-free claims experience

  • Timeliness of payouts

  • Agent courtesy and communication

  • Satisfaction with premiums paid

Amica, USAA, and Auto-Owners Insurance top the list, earning high praise across all categories. On the other hand, companies like Allstate, Farmers, and American Family received lower scores due to delays and poor claims handling.

Chart comparing top insurance companies for roofing claims based on customer satisfaction, damage estimates, agent service, and payment timeliness.


🏆 Top Performers: Roofing Claims Made Easy

If you’re looking for the best insurance company for roofing claims, start with:

  • Amica (94 score) – Known for fast, fair damage estimates and excellent customer care

  • USAA (92) – Especially strong with military families and smooth claims handling

  • Auto-Owners (89) – Delivers consistent performance across all claim categories

These insurers are trusted to support homeowners after storm damage without unnecessary delays or disputes.


⚠️ Struggling with Your Insurance Provider?

Not every homeowner is insured with a top-rated company. If you’re dealing with Allstate, Farmers, or Liberty Mutual, you may need extra help to make your case. That’s where Mastercraft Roofing LLC comes in.


🛠️ How Mastercraft Roofing LLC Helps You

At Mastercraft Roofing, we specialize in helping homeowners:

  • Identify roof damage with certified inspections

  • Document and photograph every issue clearly

  • Work with your insurance provider—good or bad

  • Guide you through the entire claims process

With HAAG-Certified Inspector Tony Bryant on your side, your claim is backed by professional evidence and experience that insurance companies respect.


📞 Need Help With a Roofing Claim?

If you’re in Perrin, Texas or surrounding areas, don’t go through the claim process alone. Contact Mastercraft Roofing LLC for a certified inspection, honest guidance, and expert claim assistance.

Call today at 817-727-2744 or request a free estimate online.

author avatar
BRYANT.TONY7